The Argument from Reason Revisited
Abstract
Arguments against naturalism and materialism have a long history, from Plato to Plantinga. The paper has three parts: First, I reconstruct an argument from reason found in Plato’s the Phaedo. Second I consider whether the argu‑ ment is relevant to contemporary forms of naturalism. I argue that the argument does constitute a serious objection to some forms of naturalism. I then defend the argument against objections from GEM Anscombe, Graham Oppy, and Peter van Inwagen.
References
Anscombe, G. E. M. 1975. “The First Person.” In Mind and Language, edited by Samuel Guttenplan, 45–65. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Anscombe, G. E. M. 1981. Metaphysics and the Philosophy of Mind. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Chisholm, Roderick. 1977. Theory of Knowledge. 2nd ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Cumhaill, Clare Mac, and Rachael Wiseman. 2023. Metaphysical Animals: How Four Women Brought Philosophy Back to Life. New York: Anchor Books.
Dennett, Daniel C. 1976. “Why the Law of Effect Will Not Go Away.” Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 5 (2): 169–187. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-5914.1975.tb00350.x.
Dennett, Daniel C.. 1992. Consciousness Explained. New York: Back Bay Books.
Ewing, A. C. 1934. Idealism: A Critical Study. London: Methuen.
Goetz, Stewart. 2018. C. S. Lewis. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.
Hasker, William. 2022. “Reply to My Friendly Critics.” Roczniki Filozoficzne 70 (1): 191–223. https://doi.org/10.18290/rf2201.12.
Inwagen, Peter van. 2024. “Afterword.” In The Origin of the Soul, edited by Joshua R. Farris and Joanna Leidenhag, 255–268. London: Routledge.
Oppy, Graham. 2022. “Anti-Naturalistic Arguments from Reason.” Roczniki Filozoficzne 70 (1): 15–35. http://doi.org/10.18290/rf2201.2.
Papineau, David. 1993. Philosophical Naturalism. Oxford: Blackwell.
Papineau, David. 2008. “Explanatory Gap and Dualist Intuitions.” In Frontiers of Consciousness, edited by Lawrence Weiskrantz and Martin Davies, 55–87. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Plato. 1969. The Complete Works of Plato. Edited by Edith Hamilton. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Rickabaugh, Brandon, and Todd Buras. 2017. “The Argument from Reason and Mental Drainage: A Reply to Peter van Inwagen.” Philosophia Christi 19 (2): 381–399. https://doi.org/10.5840/pc201719230.
Rosenberg, Alex. 2011. The Atheist’s Guide to Reality: Enjoying Life without Illusions. New York: W. W. Norton.
Taliaferro, Charles. 1994. Consciousness and the Mind of God. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Taliaferro, Charles. 2001. “Sensibility and Possibilia.” Philosophia Christi 3 (2): 403–420. https://doi.org/10.5840/pc20013240.
Taliaferro, Charles. 2015. “Abstract Objects and Causation: Bringing Causation Back into Contemporary Platonism.” Revista Portuguesa de Filosofia 71 (4): 769–780. https://doi.org/ 10.17990/rpf/2015_71_4_0769.
Taliaferro, Charles. 2018. “Substance Dualism: A Defense.” In The Blackwell Companion to Substance Dualism, edited by Jonathan J. Loose, Angus J. L. Menuge, and J. P. Moreland, 41–60. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.
Copyright (c) 2025 Forum Philosophicum
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
- When submitting a text, the author declares that he/she is the Author of the article (hereinafter referred to as the “Work”) and:
- he/she owns the exclusive and unlimited copyright to the Work,
- is entitled to dispose of the copyright to the Work.
Declares that it does not infringe any third party copyrights or legal rights.
Declares that there is no conflict of interest.
2. At the same time, the Author grants the Ignatianum University in Cracowa royalty-free, non-exclusive and territorially unlimited licence to use the Work in the following fields of exploitation:
- recording the Work in a hard copy, as well as on a digital or magnetic medium;
- reproduction of the Work using any technique, without limitation of the number of editions or copies;
- distribution of the Work and its copies on any medium, including marketing, sale, lending, and rental;
- introduction of the Work into a computer memory;
- disseminating the Work in information networks, including in the Internet;
- public performance, exhibition, display, reproduction, broadcasting and re-broadcasting, as well as making the Work available to the public in such a way that everyone can have access to it at a time and place of their own choosing;
- within the scope of dependent rights to the Work, including in particular the right to make necessary changes to the Work resulting from editorial and methodical development, as well as to translate the Work into foreign languages;
The licence is granted from the moment of the transfer of the Work to the Ignatianum University in Cracow. The Ignatianum University in Cracow is entitled to grant further sub-licences to the Work within the scope of the right granted. The licence is time-limited and it is granted for a period of 15 years, starting from the date of its granting.
Authors are permitted and encouraged to publish their text online (e.g. in their institution’s repository or on the institution’s website) before or during the submission process as this may lead to beneficial exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of the published text (See The Effect of Open Access). We recommend using any of the following portals of research associations:
- ResearchGate
- SSRN
- Academia.edu
- Selected Works
- Academic Search
