The State of the Church – Great Diplomacy of a Small State
Abstract
The paper presents the historiographical considerations about if and why one could insert the early modern State of the Church into the concept of a “small state” and, at the same time, what were the reasons for the great diplomatic success of Rome during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. The activity of papal diplomacy is shown as primarily focused on affirming the dualistic authority of the early modern Holy See (both as of a secular territorial state and a universal monarchy of religious character). The analysis also concerns the papal attitude of “active neutrality” as a political and diplomatic strategy focused on achieving the papacy’s “international” position. The profile of the paper is historiographical, as it takes from the legacies of Polish, French, German, English and Italian historical science. The enquiry aims to systematise and synthesise the former judgments of historians regarding the nature of the Papal State’s statehood in the context of the pope’s exercise of universal ecclesiastical authority.The permanent apostolic nunciatures, operating since the end of the fifteenth century, have become the core of early modern European diplomacy, guaranteeing Rome its political expansion after the Avignon crisis, despite the economic and military weakness of its territorial basis: the State of the Church. In this sense, the Papal State ceased to be a “small state” and became a universalistic entity of both political and ecclesiastical character. The Roman Curia no longer only played a passive role in “international” relations; on the contrary, thanks to the new system of permanent diplomatic representations at Catholic courts, it had the opportunity to undertake its own political initiative, act as a mediator and arbitrator, as well as strengthen the control over the religious life of European states.
References
Anderson Matthew Smith, The Rise of Modern Diplomacy 1450–1919 (London– New York: Longman, 1993).
Andretta Stefano, L’arte della prudenza. Teorie e prassi della diplomazia nell’Italia del XVI e XVII secolo (Roma: Biblink, 2006).
Andretta Stefano, “Cerimoniale e diplomazia pontificia nel XVII secolo”, in: Cérémonial et rituel à Rome: (16.°–19.° siécle), éd. Maria Antonietta Visceglia, Catherine Brice (Roma: Ecole française de Rome, 1997), 201–222.
Banaszak Marian, Z dziejów dyplomacji watykańskiej: poselstwa obediencyjne w latach 1534–1605. Cz. 3, Poselstwa monarchów i republik (Warszawa: Akademia Teologii Katolickiej, 1975).
Barbiche Bernard, “La diplomatie pontificale au XVII siècle”, in: Armées et diplomatie dans l’Europe du XVIIe siècle (Paris: Actes du Colloque de 1996. Bulletin nr 16, 1992), 109–127.
Bellini Piero, Sede Apostolica e realtà politiche fra l’Evo Medio e l’Epoca Moderna (Torino: G. Giappichelli Editore, 2015).
Bély Lucien, L’art de la paix en Europe. Naissance de la diplomatie moderne. XVIe–XVIIIe siècle (Paris: PUF, 2007).
Bély Lucien, “La médiation diplomatique au XVIIe siècle et au début du XVIIIe siècle”, in: Armées et diplomatie dans l’Europe di XVIIe siècle (Paris: Actes du Colloque de 1996. Bulletin nr 16, 1992), 129–147.
Blet Pierre, Historie de la Représentation Diplomatique du Saint Siège des origines à l’aube du XIX siècle (Città del Vaticano: Archivio Vaticano, 1990).
Caravale Mario, Alberto Caracciolo, Lo Stato Pontificio da Martino V a Pio IX (Torino: UTET, 1978).
Cardinale Igino, Le Saint-Siège et la diplomatie: aperçu historique, juridique et pratique de la diplomatie pontificale (Paris: Desclée, 1962).
Carta Paolo, Dorota Gregorowicz, “Nunziature e politica nel ‘500. L’istituto e i suoi aspetti critici”, in: Ambassades et ambassadeurs en Europe (XVe– XVIIe siècles), éd. Jean Louis Fournel, Matteo Residori (Genève: Droz, 2020), 441–466.
Fedele Dante, Naissance de la diplomatie moderne (XIIIe–XVIIe siècles): l’ambassadeur au croisement du droit, de l’ethique et de la politique (BadenBaden: Nomos, Dike, 2017).
Feldkamp, Michael Frank, La diplomazia pontificia. Da Silvestro I a Giovanni Paolo II: un profilo (Milano: Jaca Book, 1998).
Fletcher Catherine, Diplomacy in Renaissance Rome: The Rise of the Resident Ambassador (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015).
Gentili Alberico, De iure belli libri tres (Hanoviae: Excudebat Guilielmus Antonius, 1598).
Gregorowicz Dorota, “Problem papieskiej neutralności wobec rywalizacji o tron w Rzeczypospolitej w wyniku abdykacji Jana Kazimierza Wazy”, in: Sztuka roztropności. Dyplomacja Stolicy Apostolskiej wobec Rzeczypospolitej, Europy i świata, red. Krzysztof Ożóg, Ryszard Skowron (Kraków: Polska Akademia Umiejętności, 2020), 141–161.
Gregorowicz Dorota, Tiara w grze o koronę. Stolica Apostolska wobec wolnych elekcji w Rzeczypospolitej Obojga Narodów w drugiej połowie XVI w. (Kraków: Polska Akademia Umiejętności, 2019).
Grotius Hugo, De iure belli ac pacis (Parisiis: Apud Nicolaum Buon, 1625).
Hugon Alain, Rivalités européennes et hégémonie mondiale, XVIe–XVIIIe siècle (Paris: Armand Colin, 2002).
Livet Georges, L’équilibre européen de la fin du XVe à la fin du XVIIIe siècle (Paris: PUF, 1976).
Mallet Michael Edward, Diplomacy and War in Later Fifteenth-Century Italy (London: British Academy, 1981).
Mattingly Garret, Renaissance Diplomacy (London: Penguin Books, 1965).
Pastor von Ludwig, Storia dei papi dalla fine del Medio Evo compilata con sussidio dell’Archivio segreto pontificio e di molti altri Archivi. Vol. IX, Storia dei papi nel periodo della Riforma e restaurazione cattolica. Gregorio XIII (1572–1585) (Roma: Desclée, 1925).
Pieper Anton, Zur Entstehungsgeschichte der ständigen Nuntiaturen (Freiburg: Herder, 1894).
Pizzorusso Giovanni, “Appunti sulle edizioni documentarie delle «Nunziature d’Italia»”, in: Gli archivi della Santa Sede come fonte per la storia moderna e contemporanea, a cura di Matteo Sanfilippo, Giovanni Pizzorusso (Viterbo: Sette città, 2001), 33–58.
Poumarède Géraud, Il Mediterraneo oltre le crociate. La guerra turca nel Cinquecento e nel Seicento tra leggende e realtà (Torino: UTET, 2011).
Prodi Paolo, Il sovrano pontefice: un corpo e due anime. La monarchia papale nella prima età moderna (Bologna: Il Mulino, 2013) (first edition – 1982).
Prodi Paolo, Diplomazia del Cinquecento: instituzioni e prassi (Bologna: Patron, 1963).
Ranke von Ludwig, Storia dei papi (Firenze: Sansoni, 1965).
Raviola Blythe Alice, L’Europa dei piccoli stati: dalla prima età moderna al declino dell’antico regime (Roma: Carocci, 2008).
Riccardi Luca, “An Outline of Vatican Diplomacy in the Early Modern Age”, in: Politics and Diplomacy in Early Modern Italy. The Structure of Diplomatic Practice, 1450–1800, ed. by Daniela Frigo (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000), 95–108.
Rosa Mario, La Curia romana in età moderna (Roma: Viella, 2013).
Schilling Heinz, “Die konfessionellen Glaubenskriege und die Formierung des frühmodernen Europa”, in: Glaubenskriege in Vergangenheit und Gegenwart, ed. by Peter Herrmann (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck& Ruprecht, 1996), 123–137.
Schilling Heinz, Konfesjonalizacja. Kościół i państwo w Europie doby przednowoczesnej (Poznań:Wydawnictwo Poznańskie, 2010).
Schilling Heinz, “Konfessionalisierung und Formierung eines internationalen Systems während der frühen Neuzeit”, in: Die Reformation in Deutschland und Europa. Interpretationen und Debatten, ed. Hans R. Guggisberg and Gottfried G. Krodel (Gütersloh: Gütersloher Verlagshaus, 1993), 591–613.
Schilling Heinz, “The Two Papal Souls and the Rise of an Early Modern State System”, in: Papato e politica internazionale nella prima età moderna, a cura di Maria Antonietta Visceglia (Roma: Viella, 2013), 103–116.
Silvano Giordano, “Uomini e apparati della politica internazionale del papato”, in: Papato e politica internazionale nella prima età moderna, a cura di Maria Antonietta Visceglia (Roma: Viella, 2013), 131–148.
Tallon Alain, “Conflicts et médiationes dans la politique internationale de la papauté”, in: Papato e politica internazionale nella prima età moderna, a cura di Maria Antonietta Visceglia (Roma: Viella, 2013), 118–119.
Tallon Alain, L’Europa del Cinquecento. Stati e relazioni internazionali (Roma: Carocci, 2013).
Tallon Alain, “Les missions de paix de la papauté au XVIe siècle”, in: Guerres et paix en Europe centrale aux époques moderne et contemporaine. Mélanges d’histoire des relations internationales offerts à Jean Bérenger, éd. Daniel Tollet, Paris: Presses de l’Université Paris-Sorbonne, 2003), 165–180.
Tygielski Wojciech, Z Rzymu do Rzeczypospolitej. Studia z dziejów nuncjatury apostolskiej w Polsce, XVI i XVII w. (Warszawa: Wydawnictwa Fundacji „Historia pro Futuro”, 1992).
Verga Marcello, “L’Impero in Italia. Alcune considerazioni introduttive”, in: L’Impero e l’Italia nella prima età moderna / Das Reich und Italien in der Frühen Neuzeit, a cura di Matthias Schnettger, Marcello Verga (BolognaBerlin: Il Mulino-Duncker&Humblot, 2006), 11–24.
Visceglia Maria Antonietta, “Il cerimoniale come linguaggio politico”, in: Cérémonial et rituel à Rome: (16.°–19.° siécle), éd. Maria Antonietta Visceglia, Catherine Brice (Roma: Ecole française de Rome, 1997), 117–176.
Visceglia Maria Antonietta, Roma papale e Spagna. Diplomatici, nobili e religiosi tra le due corti (Roma: Bulzoni, 2010).
Visceglia Maria Antonietta, “The International Policy of the Papacy: Critical Approaches to the Concepts of Universalism and Italianità: Peace and War”, in: Papato e politica internazionale nella prima età moderna, a cura di Maria Antonietta Visceglia (Roma: Viella, 2013), 17-62.
Wojtyska Henryk Damian, Papiestwo – Polska 1548–1563 (Lublin: Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski, 1977).
Wojtyska, Henryk Damian, “Prymasostwo – nuncjatura. Dzieje relacji instytucjonalnych”, in: Prymasi i prymasostwo w dziejach państwa i narodu polskiego, red. Wiesław Jan Wysocki (Warszawa: Pax, 2002), 85–107.
Fattori Maria Teresa, “Per una storia della curia romana dalla riforma sistina, secoli XVI–XVIII”, Storia del cristianesimo 35/3 (2014): 787–848.
Galasso Giuseppe, “Le relazioni internazionali nell’età moderna (secoli XV– XVIII)”, Rivista Storica Italiana 111/1 (1999): 5–36.
Sowerby Tracey, “Early Modern Diplomatic History”, History Compass 14/9 (2016): 441–456.
Copyright (c) 2022 Jesuit University Ignatianum in Krakow
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The Yearbook only accepts materials for publication that are free of all conflicts of interest, and that in no way involve conflicts over authorship, copyright, etc. The Editors will take action against any cases of plagiarizing, ghostwriting1, guest/honorary authorship2, etc. Where co-authored work is concerned, the Author listed first is expected to take responsibility for the submission, and is required to make clear the contributions of all of the Co-Authors involved. In the event of the publication owing its existence to funding dedicated to this purpose, this fact should be made clear: e.g. in any note of thanks/acknowledgement, or in a footnote, etc. Explicit notification should be given of any form of reprinting, with the appropriate evidence of permission to publish being furnished as required. Any impropriety on the part of Authors/Reviewers risks exposing them to appropriate responses from the relevant institutions.
______
1 This term refers to instances of a person who has made an essential contribution being omitted from the list of authors, or from notes conveying gratitude and/or acknowledgement.
2 This occurs when a person who has made either an insignificant contribution or no contribution at all nevertheless appears on the list of authors.
